First Team:
Offense:
- Quarterback: McKenzie Milton, Central Florida
- Running Back: Rashaad Penny, San Diego State
- Running Back: Devin Singletary, Florida Atlantic
- Wide Receiver: Anthony Miller, Memphis
- Wide Receiver: Michael Gallup, Colorado State
- Tight End: Adam Breneman, Massachusetts
- Offensive Line: Will Hernandez, UTEP
- Offensive Line: Chukwuma Okorafor, Western Michigan
- Offensive Line: Max Scharping, NIU
- Offensive Line: Jeremi Hall, South Florida
- Offensive Line: Dejon Allen, Hawaii
Defense:
- Defensive Line: Ed Oliver, Houston
- Defensive Line: Sutton Smith, NIU
- Defensive Line: Marcus Davenport, UTSA
- Defensive Line: Ja’Von Rolland-Jones, Arkansas State
- Linebacker: Shaquem Griffin, Central Florida
- Linebacker: Ulysees Gilbert, Akron
- Linebacker: Leighton Vander Esch, Boise State
- Defensive Back: Jeremy Reaves, South Alabama
- Defensive Back: Parry Nickerson, Tulane
- Defensive Back: Andrew Wingard, Wyoming
- Defensive Back: Delvon Randall, Temple
Special Teams:
- Return Specialist: Tony Pollard, Memphis
- Punter: Corey Bojorquez, New Mexico
- Kicker: Dominik Eberle, Utah State
Second Team:
Offense:
- Quarterback: Riley Ferguson, Memphis
- Running Back: D'Angelo Brewer, Tulsa
- Running Back: Diocemy Saint Juste, Hawaii
- Wide Receiver: Courtland Sutton, SMU
- Wide Receiver: Anthony Johnson, Buffalo
- Tight End: Jake Roh, Boise State
- Offensive Line: Gabe Kuhn, Memphis
- Offensive Line: Elijah Nkansah, Toledo
- Offensive Line: Steven Rowzee, Troy
- Offensive Line: Austin Corbett, Nevada
- Offensive Line: Antonyo Woods, Florida Atlantic
Defense:
- Defensive Line: Justin Lawler, SMU
- Defensive Line: Anthony Winbush, Ball State
- Defensive Line: Maxx Crosby, EMU
- Defensive Line: Oshane Ximines, Old Dominion
- Linebacker: Genard Avery, Memphis
- Linebacker: Frank Ginda, San José State
- Linebacker: Dalton Herrington, New Mexico State
- Defensive Back: Darius Phillips, WMU
- Defensive Back: Jalen Davis, Utah State
- Defensive Back: Clifton Duck, Appalachian State
- Defensive Back: Jalen Young, Florida Atlantic
Special Teams:
- Return Specialist: Darius Phillips, WMU
- Punter: Joe Davidson, BGSU
- Kicker: Emilio Nadelman, South Florida
Third Team:
Offense:
- Quarterback: Logan Woodside, Toledo
- Running Back: Terry Swanson, Toledo
- Running Back: Ito Smith, Southern Miss
- Wide Receiver: Cedrick Wilson, Boise State
- Wide Receiver: Diontae Johnson, Toledo
- Tight End: Ryan Yurechek, Marshall
- Offensive Line: Colby Gossett, Appalachian State
- Offensive Line: Jake Bennett, Colorado State
- Offensive Line: Brandon Ray, Western Kentucky
- Offensive Line: Aaron Evans, Central Florida
- Offensive Line: Lanard Bonner, Arkansas State
Defense:
- Defensive Line: Curtis Weaver, Boise State
- Defensive Line: Joe Ostman, CMU
- Defensive Line: Carl Granderson, Wyoming
- Defensive Line: Tee Sims, Appalachian State
- Linebacker: Auggie Sanchez, South Florida
- Linebacker: Khalil Hodge, Buffalo
- Linebacker: Tony Lashley, Idaho
- Defensive Back: Darious Williams, UAB
- Defensive Back: Mike Hughes, Central Florida
- Defensive Back: Amari Coleman, CMU
- Defensive Back: Kameron Kelly, San Diego State
Special Teams:
- Punter: Corliss Waitman, South Alabama
- Kicker: Wyatt Bryan, Colorado State
- Return Specialist: Rashaad Penny, San Diego State
Superlatives:
- Offensive Player of the Year: Rashaad Penny, San Diego State
- Defensive Player of the Year: Ed Oliver, Houston
- Coach of the Year: Lane Kiffin, Florida Atlantic
- Team of the Year: Central Florida
- Game of the Year: Central Florida 62, Memphis 55 (AAC title game)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- Mountain West: 19 (7 first team)
- American: 18 (8 first team).
- MAC: 17 (4 first team)
- Conference USA: 10 (3 first team)
- Sun Belt: 10 (2 first team)
- Independent: 1 (1 first team)
